Books and games, charted the way I chart everything else. 10 games logged · 10 books logged
Reid's Notes

Book

Circe: a slow burn that earned the wait

★★★★★

December 28, 2025 · by Reid Callahan

Cover art for Circe

I started this one on a Tuesday that turned into a pileup of minor MVAs, the kind where nobody’s critical but everybody’s loud, and I want to be honest, the first thirty pages didn’t grab me the way a triage read usually demands something grab me fast or get set down. Circe’s childhood among the gods is cold on purpose, Miller wants you to feel how unwanted this kid is, and it’s not exactly a hook. Stick with it. Once she’s exiled to Aiaia the book finds its actual pulse and doesn’t let go.

What got me is how Miller writes power as something learned in private, in repetition, the way you learn a skill nobody’s grading you on. Circe turns men into pigs and everyone remembers that detail, but the book cares more about the thousand small hours of her figuring out herbs and tides and what she actually wants, alone, with nobody watching. That’s a shift-work kind of competence. You don’t get good at something because it’s dramatic. You get good because you did it again at 4am when nobody was checking.

The Odysseus stretch is fine, it’s the part everyone talks about, but the back half with Telegonus and the reckoning with her own family is where the book earns its rating. There’s a scene near the end, her choice about mortality, that I sat with for longer than I expected to. That’s rare for me. Most books I close and move to the next chart. This one needed a minute.

Held up fine across interrupted reading too, chapters are long but each one has its own gravity, so picking it back up after a call bell didn’t cost me anything. Five stars, no hedging.

← Back to everything